Do you ever wonder why certain people come into your life? Is it for a reason? Is there a lesson to be learned? Or is it just coincidence? Is there no deeper meaning at all?
I want there to be a reason. I want to believe in fate. I want my life to have meaning. Why? I suppose because the alternative is scary. To accept that things just happen at random means facing the powerlessness I have over my life. It means accepting that, despite all my best intentions, things may not go the way I want them to. Bad things will happen. Good things will too. Against my will. In spite of my efforts.
I’m not sure what the right answer is to these questions. I imagine, like so much of life, it is somewhere in the middle, in that gray space. Life is unpredictable in a predictable way. We may not be able to control everything that happens, but we do control our reactions to the things that happen. What causes what is complicated. It is nuanced. Every day I am learning to sit with that.
I recently started talking again to someone from my past. He is someone that I used to feel very attached to. Perhaps dependent on is a better way of framing it. His mom had passed away within the last couple of years when we met. When I first met him, though, he was goofy and always joking around. I actually questioned whether he was capable of being serious. He reacted to that assumption I made and called me out on judging him too quickly. I remember feeling bad. I’m not sure if I felt bad for what I did to him or felt bad for being criticized – probably both. I felt I needed to keep talking to him, to figure out who he really was.
So we did. This was 2018. To say this relationship has been tumultuous would be an understatement.
It became an unhealthy dynamic for me very quickly. It was the oh so common trap of wanting someone you can never have. It didn’t take long before we were spending hours on the phone, and I truly enjoyed that time. It was both witty banter and deep conversations about what we had been through. It had become very important to me that I find someone with a sense of humor, but an ability to be serious at the right times. I felt like I found that in him.
Despite all the communicating, he wouldn’t commit. I wanted the constant communication to mean we were in a relationship, but when I told him I wanted to date only him, he replied with the “I’m not in a good enough place to be in a relationship.” It is true. He wasn’t. But we acted like we were without the label and that was confusing for me. And it hurt.
He told me to date, and he went on some dates too. However, he would then use the fact that I had gone on other dates as “evidence” that I didn’t really want to be with him. I would defend myself and he would twist it around so it became my fault. Every. Single. Time.
We continued to talk, but over time, the fighting was more and more frequent. The same push/pull dynamic played out repeatedly. I felt crazed – trying to convince someone I wanted to be with him while he was actually pushing me away. Once I started to move on, he became ready for a relationship, but made a point of letting me know that he had doubts about a relationship with me. I tried to hold on to my truth and not lose myself, but this relationship broke me down. The words broke me down. As Taylor Swift says, he was casually cruel in the name of being honest. I was called many names and accused of having so many terrible traits.
I did finally move on and started dating other people. Enough was enough. In response to this, I was accused of ghosting him. This was not ghosting. I’ve ghosted before (I’m not proud of it), but this was not it. This was me deciding I was worth more than the way I was being treated. This was me getting out of the trap of needing his validation. But I will never convince him of that. He will never see it from my perspective. He is the victim, and I am the one doing harm. That is his narrative.
We did occasionally talk after that. I learned that within a month or so after we stopped talking regularly he got into a relationship. I was still dating around. We attempted a friendship, but the conversation always steered back to who was to blame for what happened between us. A game I was destined to lose every time.
The fact that he got into a relationship after telling me he wasn’t ready for one with me triggered my insecurities in a soul crushing way. I was so tired of this being my story. Why was I always the one men left for greener pastures? I was trying very hard to build up my confidence, to not tie my self-worth to external validation. But, F*ck, it is hard. Really, really hard.
In my more confident moments, I can reflect on these relationships and look at them critically. I can see my role in them. I can see their role too. It can be gray. That is easier to accept. When you are in it, though, when the pain is raw, you need a place to put it. You will do anything to not feel it. That feeling of rejection. Of loss. Of what could have been but never was. In these painful moments, I turn on myself. I blame myself. I am the version of myself he painted me out to be.
From Spring 2020 to August of this year we did not speak. And during that time, I let go of the idea that we would ever be something. I continued to learn more about myself and who I want to surround myself around. Despite my ongoing struggles with OCD and bulimia, I generally feel more at ease, more settled. So why did I respond when he reached out?
Honestly? I think there are three reasons. One – It feels good to be on someone’s mind, especially when you already feel like you are easy to walk away from. I’m human and would like to feel more of that. Two – Dating hadn’t been going particularly well. There is some weird sexual energy out there following the months of isolation due to the pandemic…hang tight, I’ll share more on that in the near future. Finally, three – I think I was genuinely curious to see how he was. Contrary to his belief, I am not actually a monster.
Up until three weeks ago I was really enjoying catching up. I told him I needed to ease back into being in each other’s lives again and he seemed to respect that. Though, it didn’t take long until we were talking daily, including over the phone. The banter was fun. The conversations were real. I had always genuinely appreciated his comfort in sharing his emotions. They did not make me uncomfortable when I wasn’t the target of his negative feelings. When things were on good terms between, they felt really good. I let myself consider the possibility that maybe he was in a better place these days.
And then poof, it switched. I wasn’t there for him in the way he expected. He was having a difficult week and so was I. I was honest about the fact that I was struggling. I told him I had less energy to give for that reason. Still, I was accused of distancing. “You always do this.” “Would have been nice if you asked about my interviews.” For the record, I didn’t even know these interviews were happening.
I knew following this exchange of messages that letting him back in my life was a mistake. There will never be any space for me in this relationship. His needs will always take priority and I will be expected to carry them even when I’m on the ground struggling to get up.
In an effort to have more direct and honest conversations with the people in my life, I told him that I was hurt he hadn’t checked in with me to see how I was doing. I told him I didn’t feel there was room for me to struggle as well.
And suddenly it was 2018 again.
I was selfish.
I was imploding so badly he had a hard time watching it.
I flip and let emotions cloud me.
I am unstable.
I am entitled.
I am like talking to a 4th grader.
I was destructive.
I was using him and taking advantage of his kindness.
I was an asshole.
All these things were said plus more. I will admit my anger led to me saying some regrettable things. There is something so anxiety-provoking about someone who tries to rob you of your truth like he does. Every time the story is twisted and I become demonized.
The last message I sent was an apology for the hurtful things I said when angry and defensive. I do wish I was able to control my emotions more in the moment and disengage, but I am imperfect.
I own this. When provoked, I am capable of saying hurtful things.
But that is all I owed him. Me owning my part. But I refuse to own his too. I refuse to carry his anger, frustration, and pain on my back. I refuse to be a projection of his anxiety. I will not let him or anyone else weigh me down so they can feel lighter. I will not be silenced so they can yell louder.
This is progress and no one can take that away.
Cue ‘All Too Well’ by Taylor Swift